The Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association (CTPA) devoted its inaugural scientific conference to the question of how government, industry and the media can counter misinformation about beauty products. The members-only event, held at Central Hall Westminster in London, brought together speakers who returned repeatedly to a small set of practical tactics: placing numbers in context, speaking with a consistent voice and starting from where consumers already are.
Context before numbers
In her opening remarks, Caroline Rainsford, director of science at the CTPA, said strong science communication is essential because everyone involved spends their days translating complicated scientific information into something audiences can manage. Speaking later on a panel about building trust, she said context is what makes a technical limit meaningful to a consumer.
She recalled explaining an ingredient restriction in nail polish to salon professionals by pointing out that a person would have to wear two kilograms of nail polish to approach the level that causes harm, and said that putting things into context is what genuinely speaks to people.
Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, offered a comparable device for communicating concentration. An Olympic swimming pool, he noted, would take one person around 4,500 years to drink at two litres a day; once that comparison is made, a drop in a pool stops sounding significant. His conclusion was that fighting misinformation begins with giving consumers the keys to measure and understand.
One voice, and its limits
Pissavini argued that credibility in science depends on consistency. He called on dermatologists, doctors and companies to speak with one voice, replacing the individual “I” with a collective “we” in the way he said pharmacy and large groups already do, which he believes would make the sector stronger.
Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK government's Office for Product Safety and Standards, found the idea interesting but noted that scientists are not especially good at it. She observed that the core of credible science is work that has been critiqued and peer-reviewed, and said the profession should become more aware of how it communicates with itself.
Pissavini, who also edits the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said preserving peer review is crucial, though the current difficulty lies in finding reviewers and in communicating the process to readers both inside and outside the industry. Rainsford added that the sector needs to work collectively to demystify what peer review means, since even industry members often do not understand how it works, and that transparency about the process will matter going forward.
Meeting people where they are
Journalist and consultant Claire Coleman said correcting misinformation should start where it circulates. The priority, she argued, is to meet people where they are and help them understand, which means identifying the location of the false claim and standing on the same platform as the audience.
Middleton agreed, reframing a government habit of talking about “hard to reach” consumers: they are not hard to reach, she said, they are hard for the industry to hear, and taking more responsibility for listening is part of the task.
Coleman cautioned, however, that the industry will not convert everyone. Its audience should not be hard-liners, she said, but the floating voters — consumers who are uncertain and trying to understand.
Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK's Chemical Industries Association, advised avoiding technical terms and acronyms where possible and framing messages from the consumer's perspective while keeping the science precise and clear. That is tricky with subjects such as risk-based exposure, he acknowledged, but it should remain the goal. He also urged a more balanced perspective: science is not necessarily black and white, transparency is key, and companies should be upfront about what remains unknown rather than avoiding awkward questions.
Emma Meredith, director-general of the CTPA, closed the conference by saying that how the industry communicates science, and that it communicates it well, is critical.
